Where Learning Happens: The Case for Reflective Practice

Reflection is treated as what comes after learning, rather than where learning happens.

On 1 December 1974, Trans World Airlines (TWA) Flight 514 was descending towards Washington Dulles through cloud and turbulence when the crew misread a clearance from air traffic control. They dropped to 1,800 feet too early and flew into the side of Mount Weather in Virginia. All 92 people on board lost their lives.

The investigation uncovered something worse than a tragic mistake. About six weeks earlier, a United Airlines crew had made the same error on the same approach and only narrowly cleared the ridge. They realized what had happened, reported it, and United warned its own pilots. But there was no way for that warning to travel any further.

The response was the creation of the NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System (ASRS), which began operating in 1976. It is voluntary, confidential and non-punitive, and it has now collected more than two million reports. Pilots, controllers and crew deliberately write up the moments that nearly went wrong, so that someone else doesn’t have to learn the same lesson the hard way.

Aviation isn’t unusual in this. In elite sport, ‘video sessions’ are an important piece of the training program, and the clips coaches focus on are mostly the breakdowns in systems and strategy, not the highlights. In surgery, morbidity and mortality conferences bring teams together to walk through the cases that didn’t go to plan. In each of these fields, structured reflection is core infrastructure.

Now compare this approach with how many courses and training programs end: with a simple feedback form. Reflection is treated as what comes after learning, rather than where learning happens.

Reflection isn’t downtime: it’s the productive part

Some of the clearest evidence for the importance of reflective practice to learning comes from researchers Giada Di Stefano, Francesca Gino, Gary Pisano and Bradley Staats, who ran a field experiment published by Harvard Business School with new employees in training at a large business process outsourcing firm in India. One group spent the last 15 minutes of each training day writing about what they had learned. The rest carried on as normal. On the final training assessment, the group that reflected scored about 23% higher.

And the results held up across further studies. In ten studies with more than 4,300 participants, including lab experiments where people chose between extra practice and time to reflect, the researchers found the same pattern. Given the choice, most people opted for more practice, assuming that doing more was the productive option. The results showed the opposite: participants who spent the time reflecting more consistently outperformed those who spent it practicing.

This trend doesn’t only apply to adults in workplace training. The UK’s Education Endowment Foundation rates metacognition and self-regulation (teaching pupils to plan, monitor and evaluate their own learning) as one of the most effective and lowest-cost approaches available to schools, reportedly worth around eight months of additional progress. Notably, the gains are even larger for primary-age pupils than for secondary schoolers.

Metacognition, which is the reflective awareness of one’s own thought processes - thinking about one’s own thinking - sits at the heart of some of the most established ideas about how we learn. MIT’s Donald Schön distinguished between reflection-in-action (the teacher who senses a lesson going wrong and changes course on the spot) and reflection-on-action (the deliberate review that happens afterwards). The second is easy to undervalue, but it’s where we have the time to question the assumptions behind our in-the-moment decisions, and over time, it’s what makes those quick judgments better. Educational theorist David Kolb’s experiential learning cycle makes the same case even more strongly, and it’s a crucial point for program designers: experience on its own doesn’t teach. It has to be “transformed” through reflective observation before it becomes a concept you can carry forward into a new situation.

That’s exactly what Di Stefano’s trainees demonstrated. The ones who skipped reflection were piling up experience without converting it into practical and applicable knowledge.

Start simple, and start young

In fact, reflection is so fundamental to the learning process that there are great examples to be found in early childhood classrooms around the world. For instance, in the HighScope preschool approach, children follow a daily “plan-do-review” sequence: they decide what they want to do, they go and do it, and then they spend 10 to 15 minutes of “recall time” talking through what they did and learned with an adult and their peers. In China’s Anji County, children end their play by drawing a picture of what they did, which a teacher writes up as the child explains it, a practice known as Play Stories. Both follow the same loop as a professional debrief, just scaled to the capabilities of a preschooler.

These structures can grow naturally with the learner. Educator Terry Borton’s famous three questions - What? So what? Now what? - work just as well for a ten-year-old as for a nursing student in providing a basic framework for reflective action.

Although reflective frameworks may become more structured as learners mature and encounter new contexts, they share the same principle: a deliberate review of past experience, followed by a decision about what to do differently in future.

When reflection goes wrong

However, it is important to add some caveats about what reflective practice actually entails. Two people can spend the same twenty minutes thinking about the same failed project. One may come out ready to tackle the problem with renewed energy, and the other might end up feeling worse than they did before.

Psychologists Paul Trapnell (Ohio State University) and Jennifer Campbell (University of British Columbia) drew this distinction in 1999, separating reflection from rumination. On the surface, the two look the same: a person thinking hard about themselves and their experiences. But the key difference, according to the researchers, is that they’re driven by different motives. Reflection is driven by curiosity about how things work. Rumination is driven by “threat, fear and self-doubt,” and it tends to dwell on the same thoughts without leading to action.

That threat response helps explain why we struggle to learn from failure in the first place. In a series of studies, Lauren Eskreis-Winkler and Ayelet Fishbach of the University of Chicago gave people questions with two possible answers, then told them whether they’d got each one right or wrong. Because there were only two options, both kinds of feedback revealed the correct answer. Yet when people were tested again, they’d learned less from being told they were wrong than from being told they were right. The researchers’ explanation was that failure makes us feel bad about ourselves, so instead of getting curious about what went wrong, we tune out. Tellingly, people learned just as much from other people’s failures as from their successes, which suggests the problem is our ego, not the information. The precise mechanism is still being debated (a 2025 commentary challenged the original method, and the authors responded), but the implication for program design is clear: when people feel threatened, they tend to disengage.

Some organizations have designed around this challenge directly. In 2014, pediatric intensive care consultant Adrian Plunkett launched Learning from Excellence at Birmingham Children’s Hospital. Staff use a simple form to report examples of excellent practice they’ve witnessed, and the colleague involved is thanked directly. The unit then holds “appreciative inquiry” sessions to study what made those moments work. Because it starts from success rather than failure, it lets people examine their practice without feeling under threat.

Taken together, the research points to three simple rules for any reflective exercise:

  • Ask about the situation, not the self. “What made that hard?” invites analysis. “Why did I mess that up?” invites rumination.

  • Ask open-ended questions. “Did it work?” can be answered with a simple yes or no, and it only reports the result. “What made it work?” asks you to make sense of the experience, which is where the learning happens.

  • End every reflection with a concrete next step. For each question about what happened, ask what you’ll do as a result, and be specific about when and how. Insights that aren’t linked to action are unlikely to change anything.

Reflection as practice

If one idea runs through all of this research, it’s that reflection isn’t something you do after the learning. It is the learning. Experience gives us the raw material, but nothing sticks until we stop and make sense of it.

Good reflection usually starts with a good question, and that’s the thinking behind interstory, the app we built at Bon Education to make reflective practice easier to sustain. Its growing library of question decks is designed to interrupt habitual thinking, so you can turn any moment into a chance to reflect: at the end of a week, after a project wraps up, or as part of a team debrief.

To get started, here are five questions from interstory’s Powerful Questions deck that connect to the research above. Take one per sitting and give it 10 to 15 minutes, using the smaller prompts to push your thinking further.

  1. What is this really about? Principles, motives, stakes, goals, values, emotions. Pick something that’s on your mind at the moment: a decision, a frustration, or a project that’s going well. The first answer to what it’s about is usually the surface one, so keep asking until you reach what’s really driving it. That’s often where the real problem, or the real opportunity, turns out to be.

  2. How else might you look at this? A different point of view. Someone else’s shoes. A different role. A different goal. Take something that didn’t go to plan and look at it from a different angle. A little distance from our own perspective makes it easier to stay curious about what happened and what it can teach us.

  3. What assumptions are you making? Are they true? How might you find out? When we’re busy, we act on assumptions without stopping to check them. Reflection gives us the chance to look back and ask which ones are still working for us and which ones might be worth rethinking. Often that’s where the most useful lessons are hiding.

  4. What is the pattern? What repeats? What rhymes? What keeps happening? Look across what’s gone great as well as what hasn’t. Kolb’s point was that experience only teaches once it becomes a concept you can carry into a new situation. Spotting a pattern is how a single experience becomes that kind of lesson.

  5. What needs to shift? Something big or small? Flip the switch. What happens? Borton’s framework ends with “Now what?” for a reason: reflection is most valuable when it shapes what you do next. Name one specific thing you’ll do differently, and who would notice if you did.

These five questions are only a starting point. The rest of the deck and interstory’s other tools are at www.interstory.com! We’d love to hear how it goes for you or your team, so share your reflections on LinkedIn and tag us so we can learn from it too!

About Bon Education

At Bon Education, our learning programs are founded on the pedagogical foundations of Holistic Safety, Social Connection, Engagement & Fun and Mastery of Content, with reflection built in from the start.

Please contact us to learn more about how we turn goals and outcomes into meaningful learning experiences.

More

insights

Where Learning Happens: The Case for Reflective Practice

Our latest article looks at how aviation, elite sport and surgery have made structured reflection core infrastructure, and what anyone designing a learning program can borrow from them. We also explore why reflection can slide into rumination, and share three simple rules for designing reflective exercises that lead to action.

Lighting the Internal Spark: How to Design Programs for Intrinsic Motivation

When we design for short-term incentives, we risk designing for compliance, not engagement. To build programs that transform learners long after the course ends, we must design for intrinsic motivation. In this article, drawing on educational research and insights from Self-Determination Theory, we explore how to do just that.

Put your values into action

program

your impact

Person making a technichal drawn

Put your values into action

program

your impact

Person making a technichal drawn

Put your values into action

program

your impact

Person making a technichal drawn

build with

bon

Keep up to date with BON. Enter your email below to join our newsletter list.
Follow us
Contact Info
Location

Ras al Khaimah Abu Dhabi United Arab Emirates

© 2026 Bon Education FZ-LLC. All Rights Reserved. Illustrations created with Midjourney.

build with

bon

Keep up to date with BON. Enter your email below to join our newsletter list.
Follow us
Contact Info
Location

Ras al Khaimah Abu Dhabi United Arab Emirates

© 2026 Bon Education FZ-LLC. All Rights Reserved. Illustrations created with Midjourney.

build with

bon

Keep up to date with BON. Enter your email below to join our newsletter list.
Follow us
Contact Info
Location

Ras al Khaimah Abu Dhabi United Arab Emirates

© 2026 Bon Education FZ-LLC. All Rights Reserved. Illustrations created with Midjourney.